Eyebrow Gel – Which Eyebrow Gel is Right For You?

Eyebrow gel is a makeup must-have for anyone who wants to keep their brows tamed all day long. But there are tons of options out there, so how do you pick the right one for you?

The Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab tested tons of them to find the best. Check out our expert- and shopper-recommended picks for every brow shade, including tinted ones that won’t budge.

Best Overall

While pencils help you carve out a shape and powder fills in sparse areas, eyebrow gel is your finishing touch to keep brows tame and looking polished all day. There are a variety of products to choose from, including basic transparent ones and those that contain brow-enhancing microfibres and conditioning ingredients that strengthen them.

This clear brow gel from a renowned eyebrow brand was a favorite of one of our testers because it has a flexible hold and a precision makeup brush that deposits just the right amount of product for a pretty yet functional result. It also helped her tame errant hairs and lock in a defined look.

Another top pick among our testers, this eyebrow gel is lightweight and comes in a range of shades. It has a small applicator that makes it easy to apply the product precisely and works well on thin brows. This eyebrow gel also provides a boost of color for darker brows.

Best Tinted

This tinted eyebrow gel is ideal for those with thin, light, or grey brows. It creates a natural look, adds pigment, and helps fill in fine hairs for a fuller appearance. The precise applicator and gel-based formula make it easy to use, even if you’re not used to using a brow gel.

This clear brow gel has an excellent, flexible hold. It’s a great option for those who like to shape their brows with makeup and want something that will keep them in place all day. Our tester loved that it didn’t flake or feel sticky.

This tinted brow gel from Benefit is a must-try. It instantly tints and shapes your brows, and it contains a blend of keratin and gingko biloba to help you grow more full-looking brow hairs over time. It comes with a brush and sponge tip so you can get the perfect finish every time. It’s also waterproof and smudge-proof so it won’t wash off during the day.

Best for Thick Brows

If you have thick brows, you’ll want a gel that can handle the power of those hairs. This clear gel from celebrity eyebrow stylist Joey Healy—who has tame-ed arches of clients including Kyra Sedgwick and Andy Cohen—is one of the best we’ve ever tested, as it offers a soft hold that doesn’t feel crunchy. It’s also water-resistant and perfect for those hot, humid summer days.

Another option for thick brows is this volumizing gel from Eyeko, which earned a perfect score in our testing and has an innovative applicator that doubles as a highlighter for the eyebrow arch. The formula contains keratin and gingko biloba to promote healthy, fuller brows, and it comes in a range of universal shades.

For a more dramatic, long-lasting look, try eyebrow wax. It’s strong enough to create a near-laminated look that can last all day. Plus, it helps to tame errant brow hairs and can be used in place of a brow pencil if you’re on the go.

Best for Soft Brows

For brows that look natural-looking and feel light to the touch, this gel is a great option. Our tester found it easy to work through her brows with the applicator, which features both short and long bristles to comb and sculpt your brows into place. She also loved how it held her brows in place all day without feeling crunchy or crusty, even in hot weather.

Users love how this long-lasting eyebrow gel has a spoolie on one end to create a more natural look and brush away any stray hairs. They say the color is rich and blends well, and the formula contains brow-loving ingredients like biotin and grape seed oil for growth.

Unlike other eyebrow gels that come in tubes similar to mascara, this product comes in a tiny pot with a small brush and spoolie. This makes it ideal for quick touch-ups or travel. The gel is enriched with nourishing ingredients like olive, shea and meadowfoam oils to keep your brows hydrated and soft. Eyebrow gel